What's the Closest Formula to Breast Milk?

The Short Answer

The closest formula to breast milk is one that mimics human milk's 60:40 whey-to-casein protein ratio. While standard cow's milk is heavily casein-dominant, brands like Kendamil and the newly launched Nara Organics adjust their protein ratios to perfectly match human milk.

These brands also use whole milk to provide Milk Fat Globule Membrane (MFGM), a crucial fat structure found naturally in breast milk. ByHeart used to be a top contender in this category, but a late-2025 recall means parents should look to European-style alternatives instead. Is Byheart Good

Why This Matters

Human breast milk is incredibly complex, composed of 87% water, 3.8% fat, 1% protein, and 7% lactose. When formula companies try to replicate this, they have to heavily modify cow or goat milk to make it digestible for human infants. Goat Vs Cow Milk Formula

The biggest hurdle is the protein structure. Cow's milk is incredibly heavy in casein, which forms hard curds in the stomach and is difficult for babies to digest. Human milk is dominant in liquid whey, which digests quickly and easily. Easiest Digest Formula

Beyond basic macros, breast milk contains bioactive components that build immunity. Things like lactoferrin and Human Milk Oligosaccharides (HMOs) actively fight pathogens in your baby's gut. Standard store-bought formulas miss these entirely. Safest Formula Brands

What Actually Makes a Formula Like Breast Milk

• Whey and Casein Proteins — Breast milk is naturally 60% whey and 40% casein, while cow's milk is exactly the opposite. Look for formulas that specifically state an adjusted 60:40 or 70:30 ratio.
• MFGM (Milk Fat Globule Membrane) — This is a complex fat layer that surrounds fat droplets in breast milk and is vital for cognitive development. Whole milk formulas retain natural MFGM, while skim-milk formulas have to add it synthetically.
• Lactoferrin — This is an iron-binding protein found in high concentrations in human colostrum and mature milk. It has powerful antimicrobial properties and is rarely found in standard formulas.
• HMOs (Human Milk Oligosaccharides) — These are special prebiotics found abundantly in breast milk that feed good gut bacteria. Only premium formulas add synthesized HMOs to replicate this immune-boosting effect.
• Lactose — This is the primary carbohydrate in human milk. Many cheap formulas replace lactose with corn syrup, which spikes blood sugar and isn't a natural primary carb for infants. Corn Syrup Baby Formula

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• 60:40 Whey-to-Casein Ratio — This ensures the formula digests quickly and mimics the exact protein profile of human milk.
• Whole Milk Base — Retains natural milk fats and MFGM, reducing the need for heavy vegetable oil blends.
• 100% Lactose — The only sweetener in the formula should be the carbohydrate naturally found in breast milk.

Red Flags:

• Corn Syrup Solids — A cheap carbohydrate replacement that has no business being the primary ingredient in infant nutrition. Is Corn Syrup Formula Bad
• Palm Oil — Used to mimic palmitic acid in breast milk, but it can bind with calcium and cause hard stools. Palm Oil Baby Formula
• Unmodified Cow's Milk Protein — If a formula doesn't mention an adjusted whey ratio, it is likely heavily casein-dominant and harder to digest.

The Best Options

If you want the closest match to breast milk, you need to prioritize whole milk and an adjusted protein ratio. Best Organic Formula

The Bottom Line

1. Check the whey-to-casein ratio first. A 60:40 split is the most critical factor in mimicking the digestibility of human milk.

2. Prioritize whole milk bases. Brands like Kendamil and Nara Organics retain natural milk fats, reducing the need for processed vegetable oils.

3. Avoid ByHeart for now. While it was previously a top pick for mimicking breast milk, its November 2025 recall makes it unsafe. Baby Formula Recalls

FAQ

Is European formula closer to breast milk than American formula?

European formulas often use whole milk bases and strictly ban corn syrup, making them generally closer to human milk than standard American brands. However, new US brands like Bobbie and Nara Organics are closing the regulatory gap. European Vs American Formula

Why do some formulas use corn syrup if breast milk uses lactose?

Corn syrup is cheaper than lactose and is suitable for babies with severe, medically diagnosed lactose intolerance. For the vast majority of healthy babies, lactose is the biologically appropriate carbohydrate and should be prioritized. Formula No Corn Syrup

Does my baby need added DHA?

Breast milk naturally contains DHA, but levels vary wildly based on the mother's diet. Formulas add it to guarantee consistent levels for brain development, though the extraction method (like hexane processing) matters. Dha In Formula

---

References (9)

1. 1. nih.gov
2. 2. firststepsnutrition.org
3. 3. babylist.com
4. 4. teachtoddler.com
5. 5. pickyeaterblog.com
6. 6. gimmethegoodstuff.org
7. 7. e-cep.org
8. 8. oreateai.com
9. 9. babycenter.com