Is Birch Benders Clean? Why We're Issuing a Caution

The Short Answer

Birch Benders receives a Caution rating.

The brand has undergone significant changes since its "mom and pop" days. Now owned by the parent company of Pillsbury, Birch Benders has faced serious quality control issues recently. Independent testing in July 2024 found unsafe levels of lead and cadmium in their popular Paleo mix, likely due to the cassava flour base.

Furthermore, their Keto line uses erythritol (recently linked to heart health risks) and "natural flavors," while their frozen waffles were involved in a massive Listeria recall in late 2024.

If you must use this brand, the Organic Classic Recipe is their cleanest option, as it avoids the heavy metal issues of cassava and the artificial sweeteners of the Keto line.

Why This Matters

Industrial Ownership:

Birch Benders was sold in 2023 to Hometown Food Company, a portfolio company that also owns highly processed brands like Pillsbury, Funfetti, and Hungry Jack. While acquisition doesn't always ruin a brand, it often signals a shift toward cost-cutting and mass production supply chains.

Heavy Metals in "Healthy" Flours:

We often assume "grain-free" means cleaner. However, root vegetables like cassava (tapioca) absorb heavy metals from the soil more readily than grains. In 2024, the Birch Benders Paleo mix tested positive for 17 ppb of Lead, which is over 3x the proposed action level for children's food. This isn't just a Birch Benders problem—competitor Is Simple Mills Pancake Clean|Simple Mills has faced similar test results—but it invalidates the "clean" promise of these mixes.

Safety Recalls:

In October 2024, a massive recall by TreeHouse Foods (likely the contract manufacturer for Birch Benders' frozen items) pulled millions of waffles off shelves due to Listeria contamination. This highlights the risks of third-party industrial manufacturing.

What's Actually In Birch Benders

Here is the breakdown of their three main product lines:

1. Paleo Mix (⚠️ Avoid)

The "cleanest" looking label has the biggest hidden problem.

• Cassava Starch: The likely source of the Lead and Cadmium found in testing.
• Almond Flour: Another potential source of heavy metals depending on soil quality.
• Monk Fruit: A generally safe non-nutritive sweetener, but processed.

2. Keto Mix (⚠️ Caution)

Designed for macros, not for clean ingredients.

• Erythritol: A sugar alcohol recently linked by the Cleveland Clinic to increased risk of blood clots and heart attack.
• Natural Butter Flavor: A highly processed additive used to mimic the taste of real fat without the calories.
• Palm Oil Flakes: Often problematic for environmental reasons and processing methods.

3. Organic Classic Mix (✅ Acceptable)

Surprisingly, the "standard" wheat version is the safest bet.

• Organic Wheat Flour: Being organic means it is grown without glyphosate (Roundup), a major issue in non-organic wheat. Is Quaker Oatmeal Clean
• Organic Cane Sugar: It's still sugar, but it's not a chemical substitute.
• Sodium: High. One serving has 440mg of sodium, which is nearly 20% of your daily limit.

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• USDA Organic Seal: Ensures no synthetic pesticides or glyphosate on the wheat.
• Simple Ingredient Lists: The Organic Classic mix has recognizable pantry ingredients.

Red Flags:

• "Keto" or "Paleo" Labels: In this specific category (pancakes), these often signal heavy processing (gums, flavors) or heavy metal risks (cassava).
• Erythritol: Avoid this sweetener if you have any cardiovascular concerns.
• "Natural Flavors": Found in the Keto and flavored varieties; a black box for up to 100 chemical additives.

The Best Options

If you need a convenient pancake mix, here is how the landscape looks:

The Bottom Line

1. Skip the Paleo Mix. The risk of heavy metals like Lead and Cadmium in cassava-based mixes is currently too high to recommend for daily consumption, especially for children.

2. Avoid the Frozen Waffles. The massive 2024 Listeria recall exposed vulnerabilities in their frozen supply chain. Stick to homemade or Homemade Vs Frozen Waffles|Make Your Own Frozen Waffles.

3. Buy Organic if you Buy Birch. If you love the brand, buy the Organic Classic Recipe. It avoids the chemical sweeteners and heavy metal issues of their specialty lines.

FAQ

Is Birch Benders healthy?

It depends on the product. The Organic Classic mix is a decent standard pancake mix. However, the Keto and Paleo lines have issues with processed sweeteners (erythritol) and heavy metal contamination, making them less "healthy" than they appear.

Does Birch Benders have glyphosate?

The Organic line is certified organic, meaning it is grown without glyphosate. The Paleo and Keto lines are grain-free, so they don't have glyphosate, but they have tested positive for heavy metals, which is a different toxicity concern.

Who owns Birch Benders now?

As of 2023, Birch Benders is owned by Hometown Food Company, which also owns Pillsbury, Funfetti, and Hungry Jack. It is no longer a small, independent startup.

Are Birch Benders gluten-free?

Their Paleo and Keto mixes are gluten-free, but we advise caution due to the heavy metal testing results. If you need gluten-free, consider making your own mix with organic oat flour (certified GF) to avoid the cassava risks.

---

References (11)

1. 1. alibaba.com
2. 2. apnews.com
3. 3. tamararubin.com
4. 4. tamararubin.com
5. 5. fda.gov
6. 6. clevelandclinic.org
7. 7. youtube.com
8. 8. snackandbakery.com
9. 9. foodnavigator-usa.com
10. 10. prnewswire.com
11. 11. ccf.org