What Grade of Maple Syrup Is Best?

The Short Answer

There is no single "best" grade, but there is a best grade for you.

If you are looking for the classic pancake syrup taste you grew up with, buy Grade A Amber Color, Rich Taste.

If you are looking for the nutrient-dense, strong-flavored syrup formerly known as "Grade B," you must now buy Grade A Dark Color, Robust Taste. This grade contains higher levels of antioxidants and minerals and stands up better in baking.

Ignore the letter "A" on the label. Since 2015, all retail maple syrup is "Grade A." The only thing that matters is the descriptive name (Golden, Amber, Dark, Very Dark).

Why This Matters

For decades, consumers believed "Grade A" meant high quality and "Grade B" meant industrial sludge. In reality, Grade B was just harvested later in the season, resulting in a darker color and stronger maple flavor.

Because foodies and health-conscious consumers eventually realized Grade B had more flavor and minerals, they started seeking it out. The USDA and international groups confusingly decided to rename everything Grade A to "standardize" the market.

The result? You can't find "Grade B" on shelves anymore. If you don't know the new names, you might accidentally buy "Golden" syrup (essentially sugar water with a hint of maple) when you wanted a rich, caramelized glaze for your salmon.

The New Grading System Explained

Here is how the old system maps to the current bottles on your shelf:

1. Golden Color, Delicate Taste

* Old Name: Grade A Light Amber / Fancy

* Flavor: Very mild, subtle, buttery.

* Best For: Drizzling on vanilla ice cream, yogurt, or fruit. It’s too light for pancakes; the flavor gets lost.

* Harvest Time: Early season.

2. Amber Color, Rich Taste

* Old Name: Grade A Medium Amber / Dark Amber

* Flavor: Classic, smooth maple flavor.

* Best For: Pancakes, waffles, and French toast. This is the standard "table syrup" profile.

* Harvest Time: Mid-season.

3. Dark Color, Robust Taste (The Winner 🏆)

* Old Name: Grade B

* Flavor: Intense, caramel-like, substantial.

Best For: Baking, glazing meats, sweetening oatmeal, or for people who love* maple flavor on their pancakes.

* Harvest Time: Late season.

4. Very Dark Color, Strong Taste

* Old Name: Grade C / Commercial

* Flavor: Molasses-like, slightly bitter edges.

* Best For: Industrial food processing, heavy baking (rye breads, gingerbread), or BBQ sauces where the sugar needs to caramelize deeply.

* Harvest Time: Very end of season.

Nutritional Differences

Is darker actually healthier? Yes.

As the maple season progresses, the sap changes. The microbial activity in the tree increases, converting more sucrose into invert sugars (glucose and fructose) and concentrating minerals.

* Antioxidants: Darker syrups contain significantly higher levels of polyphenols. One study found that Dark and Very Dark syrups had up to 300% higher antioxidant activity than Golden syrup.

* Minerals: Darker grades have marginally higher calcium, phosphorus, and magnesium content.

* Sugar: The calorie and sugar content is virtually identical across all grades.

The Catch: You would need to drink cups of syrup to get therapeutic doses of these minerals. While Dark is "healthier" than Golden, it is still a liquid sugar. Treat it as a treat, not a vitamin supplement. Is Maple Syrup Healthy

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• "100% Pure Maple Syrup" — The only ingredient should be maple syrup.
• Specific Origin — "Vermont," "Canada," or "Wisconsin" usually indicates better quality control than generic blends.
• Translucency — Even dark syrup should be clear, not cloudy (cloudiness indicates impurities or "sugar sand").

Red Flags:

• "Pancake Syrup" — This is corn syrup and caramel color. Pancake Syrup Vs Maple
• "Maple Flavored" — Contains little to no actual maple.
• Cloudy Sediment — If the bottle has grit at the bottom, it wasn't filtered properly.

The Best Options

The Bottom Line

1. Forget "Grade B." It's gone. Memorize "Dark, Robust" instead.

2. Buy for use. Keep a bottle of Amber for guests and pancakes, and a bottle of Dark for baking and oatmeal.

3. Read the ingredient list. If it says "High Fructose Corn Syrup," put it back. That's not maple syrup; that's lab-made sugar sludge.

FAQ

Is Grade B maple syrup better than Grade A?

Technically, Grade B no longer exists—it is now called Grade A Dark, Robust Taste. Many people consider it "better" because it has a stronger maple flavor and higher mineral content than the lighter grades, which are essentially just sweet.

Which maple syrup grade is healthiest?

Very Dark, Strong Taste and Dark, Robust Taste are the healthiest options. They contain more beneficial antioxidants and minerals (like manganese and riboflavin) than the lighter Golden and Amber grades. Is Dark Maple Syrup Healthier

Why did they change the maple syrup grades?

The USDA changed the grades in 2015 to align with international standards and to remove the stigma that "Grade B" was inferior quality. The new system emphasizes flavor descriptors (Delicate, Rich, Robust, Strong) to help consumers choose based on taste preference.

Can I use Dark syrup for pancakes?

Absolutely. In fact, many true maple lovers prefer Dark, Robust syrup on pancakes because it has a more complex, caramel-like flavor that pairs perfectly with butter. If you find standard syrup "too sweet" and "boring," switch to Dark.

---

References (19)

1. 1. azurestandard.com
2. 2. osu.edu
3. 3. tastingtable.com
4. 4. bensmaplesyrup.com
5. 5. treejuicemaplesyrup.com
6. 6. vermontmaplesyrup.com
7. 7. healthhutbrandon.ca
8. 8. coldhollow.com
9. 9. wildfoodism.com
10. 10. maplefromcanada.au
11. 11. maplefarmers.com
12. 12. nih.gov
13. 13. vermontmaple.org
14. 14. coombsfamilyfarms.com
15. 15. lcrmaplesyrup.com
16. 16. maplemountainsugarhouse.com
17. 17. cdlinc.ca
18. 18. maplefromcanada.co.uk
19. 19. nih.gov