The Short Answer
Frank's RedHot Original is technically clean, but their Buffalo Wings Sauce is highly processed. The original recipe uses just five real ingredients, making it a solid choice if you can tolerate the salt.
But the pre-mixed Buffalo Wings Sauce relies on canola oil and "natural flavors" instead of real butter. If you want a truly clean buffalo sauce, you have to make it yourself. Is Hot Sauce Healthy
Why This Matters
Frank's is the undisputed king of buffalo flavor. It's the exact brand used to invent the buffalo wing in 1964, making it a staple in American kitchens and sports bars.
But the way we consume this classic sauce has changed. Instead of mixing the Original sauce with real butter at home, most people buy the ultra-convenient Buffalo Wings Sauce right off the shelf.
Convenience almost always comes at a cost. To make a shelf-stable sauce that tastes like butter without actually using dairy, manufacturers rely on cheap seed oils and flavor lab creations.
You have to read the fine print on every bottle. If you're trying to avoid highly processed ingredients, buying the wrong version of Frank's is an easy mistake to make. Cleanest Hot Sauce
What's Actually In Frank's RedHot
We need to break down the exact ingredients found across their two most popular bottles.
Frank's RedHot Original:
- Aged Cayenne Red Peppers — Fermented peppers provide the signature heat and tang naturally.
- Distilled Vinegar — A clean, natural preservative that gives the sauce its necessary acidity.
- Water & Salt — Contributing 190mg of sodium per teaspoon, it's one of the saltiest sauces available. Hot Sauce Lowest Sodium
- Garlic Powder — A simple, single-ingredient spice added for savory depth.
Frank's RedHot Buffalo Wings Sauce:
- Canola Oil — A highly processed seed oil used to mimic the rich mouthfeel of melted butter.
- Natural Butter Type Flavor — A proprietary chemical blend engineered to taste like butter without using real dairy.
- Xanthan Gum — A common commercial thickener that helps stabilize the oil and vinegar emulsion.
What to Look For
Green Flags:
- Short ingredient lists — The Original sauce has just five easily recognizable ingredients.
- No artificial colors — The bright red color is completely natural, coming strictly from the cayenne peppers rather than synthetic dyes.
Red Flags:
- Extreme sodium levels — One tablespoon of Frank's Original contains 570mg of sodium, making it a terrible choice for high blood pressure.
- Seed oils — Any pre-made "wing sauce" is likely emulsified with cheap canola or soybean oil to cut costs.
- Natural flavors — These laboratory-made additives are used to fake the taste of real dairy in shelf-stable products.
The Best Options
If you want the classic flavor without the junk, you have to be highly specific about which bottle you buy. Sriracha Vs Franks
| Brand | Product | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Frank's RedHot | Original Cayenne Pepper Sauce | ⚠️ | Clean ingredients, but massive sodium levels. |
| Noble Made | Mild Buffalo Sauce | ✅ | Uses avocado oil instead of cheap canola oil. |
| Frank's RedHot | Buffalo Wings Sauce | 🚫 | Packed with canola oil and synthetic butter flavor. |
The Bottom Line
1. Stick to the Original. The classic Frank's RedHot recipe is made from real food ingredients and is perfectly fine for occasional use.
2. Make your own wing sauce. Skip the pre-made Buffalo version and melt your own grass-fed butter into the Original sauce.
3. Watch your sodium. If you have high blood pressure, Frank's is simply not your friend. Hot Sauce Lowest Sodium
FAQ
Does Frank's RedHot have added sugar?
No, both the Original and Buffalo versions are entirely sugar-free. This makes them incredibly popular for low-carb diets, unlike many highly sweetened condiments. Is Bbq Sauce Bad
Why is there canola oil in Frank's Buffalo Sauce?
Canola oil is cheap and shelf-stable. Real butter requires refrigeration and spoils quickly, so manufacturers use oil and xanthan gum to create a creamy texture that can sit in your pantry for months.
How much sodium is in Frank's RedHot?
A single teaspoon contains a staggering 190mg of sodium. For comparison, Tabasco contains just 35mg per teaspoon, meaning Frank's packs more than five times the salt per serving.
References (13)
- 1. recipal.com
- 2. heb.com
- 3. mifoodcity.com
- 4. hannaford.com
- 5. pepperscale.com
- 6. pepperscale.com
- 7. franksredhot.com
- 8. walmart.com
- 9. franksredhot.com
- 10. franksredhot.com
- 11. fairwaymarket.com
- 12. target.com
- 13. webstaurantstore.com