The Short Answer
Yes, rice flour contains arsenic, and it is a significant concern for anyone on a gluten-free diet. Rice is a "scavenger crop," meaning it is uniquely efficient at absorbing arsenic from soil and water. Because arsenic concentrates in the outer coating of the grain (the bran), brown rice flour often contains significantly more arsenic than white rice flour.
For most people, occasional consumption isn't a crisis. But if you are gluten-free, you are likely eating rice flour in everything from bread to crackers to cookies. Studies show that people on a gluten-free diet have nearly double the urinary arsenic levels of those who eat wheat.
Why This Matters
Arsenic isn't just a poison in mystery novels; it's a Group 1 human carcinogen. Chronic exposure to inorganic arsenicāthe type found in riceāis linked to increased risks of bladder, lung, and skin cancers, as well as heart disease and developmental issues in children.
The "healthy" choice is actually the more toxic one here. We are taught that whole grains are better, but brown rice flour averages 154 ppb (parts per billion) of inorganic arsenic, compared to about 92 ppb for white rice flour. This is because the arsenic binds to the bran layer, which is removed to make white flour but kept for brown.
Unlike whole rice, you cannot rinse rice flour. With whole grains, cooking rice in excess water (like pasta) and draining it can remove up to 40% of the arsenic. With flour, that arsenic is baked directly into your muffin or bread, meaning you ingest 100% of it. Does Rinsing Rice Remove Arsenic
What's Actually In Rice Flour
Rice flour is simpleāusually just one ingredientābut that ingredient carries baggage.
- Ground Rice Grain ā The only ingredient. If it's "Brown Rice Flour," it includes the bran and germ, which contain the highest arsenic concentrations.
- Inorganic Arsenic ā A heavy metal absorbed from soil and irrigation water. It is not an additive; it is environmental contamination, often from pesticides used decades ago on cotton fields where rice is now grown. Arsenic In Rice
- No Glyphosate (Usually) ā The good news? Unlike oats or wheat, rice is rarely desiccated with glyphosate. Testing generally shows rice flour is clean of glyphosate, so your primary worry is the heavy metal, not the herbicide. Glyphosate In Oats
What to Look For
Green Flags:
- California Basmati or Jasmine ā Rice grown in California, India, and Pakistan generally has significantly lower arsenic levels than rice from the Southern US (Arkansas, Texas, Louisiana).
- "White" Rice Flour ā While less nutritious fiber-wise, stripping the bran removes a large portion of the arsenic.
- Sorghum or Millet Blends ā These ancient grains function similarly to rice in baking but have minimal arsenic risk.
Red Flags:
- "US Grown" (Unspecified) ā If the package just says "Grown in the USA" but doesn't specify California, it likely comes from Arkansas or Louisiana, where soil arsenic levels are highest.
- Brown Rice Syrup/Flour ā Products where the first ingredient is brown rice flour or brown rice syrup will have the highest heavy metal load.
- Infant Rice Cereal ā While the FDA has set a "limit" of 100 ppb for infant cereal, consumer groups consistently find levels hovering right at or above that line.
The Best Options
If you need rice flour, geography is your best defense. Sourcing matters more than "organic" labels, because arsenic is in the soil, not a spray.
| Brand | Product | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lundberg | Organic White Rice Flour | ā | Explicitly tests for arsenic; California-grown source is naturally cleaner. |
| Authentic Foods | Superfine White Rice Flour | ā | Known for California sourcing; "Superfine" grind is better for baking texture too. |
| Bob's Red Mill | Brown Rice Flour | ā ļø | High quality, but uses mixed sourcing. Brown rice inherently has higher arsenic risks. |
| Anthony's | Brown Rice Flour | ā ļø | Sourcing varies; frequently tests higher for heavy metals in independent analyses. |
The Bottom Line
1. Don't swap wheat for just rice. If you go gluten-free, don't just replace every wheat product with a rice version. You are trading a gluten problem for an arsenic problem.
2. Lean on alternatives. Sorghum flour is the closest flavor match to wheat. Cassava flour is great for tortillas and binding. Use these to cut your rice consumption in half.
3. Choose white over brown. For flour specifically, white rice flour is the safer choice. Get your fiber from vegetables, seeds, or low-arsenic grains like quinoa and oats. White Vs Brown Rice Arsenic
FAQ
Does buying organic rice flour reduce arsenic?
No. Arsenic is a mineral in the soil and water. It is there because of historical pesticide use (decades ago) or natural geology. Organic farming practices do not remove arsenic that is already in the ground. Sourcing (where it was grown) matters far more than the organic label.
Is rice flour safe for babies?
Proceed with extreme caution. The FDA advises parents to offer a variety of fortified cereals like oat, barley, and multigrain instead of relying solely on rice. Because babies eat so much relative to their body weight, they are at the highest risk for developmental damage from arsenic exposure.
Can I wash the arsenic out of rice flour?
No. While you can rinse whole rice grains to reduce arsenic by ~30%, you cannot rinse flour. Once the rice is ground into flour, the arsenic is locked in. This is why diversifying your flour sources (using almond, coconut, or sorghum flour) is the only real way to lower exposure.
References (10)
- 1. cbsnews.com
- 2. dailyintakeblog.com
- 3. farmprogress.com
- 4. federalregister.gov
- 5. fibonaccimd.com
- 6. youtube.com
- 7. quora.com
- 8. nutritionfacts.org
- 9. food-safety.com
- 10. researchgate.net