What's the Best Canned Coconut Milk?

The Short Answer

The best canned coconut milk is Native Forest Organic Simple Coconut Milk.

It is one of the few brands that checks every box: USDA Organic, no gums (no guar or xanthan), packaged in BPA-Non-Intent cans, and explicitly PETA-verified to be free of forced monkey labor.

Trader Joe's Organic Canned Coconut Milk is the best budget alternative. It contains only coconut and water and is sourced from Sri Lanka, avoiding the ethical issues of Thai coconut farming.

Avoid "Lite" coconut milk entirely. It is simply full-fat coconut milk diluted with water (often a 1:2 ratio) and sold for the same price. Buy the full-fat can and water it down yourself to save 50% of your money.

Why This Matters

1. The "Gum" Problem

Most brands add guar gum, xanthan gum, or carrageenan to prevent the milk from separating. While convenient, these additives are common gut irritants.

• Carrageenan is the worst offender, linked to intestinal inflammation and "leaky gut." Carrageenan In Coconut Milk
• Guar Gum is a fermentable fiber that can cause significant bloating and gas, especially for those with SIBO or IBS.

2. The BPA Connection

Coconut milk is high in fat, which makes it an excellent solvent for leaching chemicals from can linings. Many cans are lined with BPA (Bisphenol A), a known endocrine disruptor that mimics estrogen. Even "BPA-Free" cans often use BPS or BPF, which have similar toxicity profiles. Look for BPA-NI (Non-Intent) cans or aseptic cartons. Is Bpa Free Lining Safe

3. The Monkey Labor Scandal

In Thailand, the coconut industry relies heavily on pig-tailed macaques—monkeys that are snatched from the wild, chained, and forced to harvest up to 1,000 coconuts a day.

• Red Flag: Coconuts from Thailand (unless certified otherwise).
• Green Flag: Coconuts from Sri Lanka, Philippines, or Vietnam, where this practice is virtually non-existent.

What's Actually In Canned Coconut Milk

A clean label should have two ingredients. Most have four or five.

• Coconut Extract: The actual food.
• Water: Necessary for processing.
• Guar Gum: A thickener derived from guar beans. Causes bloating. Is Guar Gum Safe
• Polysorbate 60: An emulsifier found in some brands (like Aroy-D cans). Linked to inflammation in animal studies.
• Sodium Metabisulfite: A preservative and allergen used to keep the coconut white.

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• "Gum Free" — Explicitly stated on the label.
• Origin: Sri Lanka / Philippines — Almost guarantees no monkey labor.
• BPA-NI — "Non-Intent" lining is the current gold standard for cans.
• Separation — If the solid cream floats to the top, that's a good sign. It means no emulsifiers were used.

Red Flags:

• "Lite" — You are paying for water.
• Origin: Thailand — High risk of monkey labor unless PETA-verified (like Native Forest).
• Smooth & Uniform — If it pours out perfectly smooth without shaking, it's full of additives.
• Polysorbate 60 — Common in "Chef's Choice" or industrial cans.

The Best Options

We analyzed ingredients, sourcing, and can safety to find the winners.

Note: Native Forest sources from Thailand but has rigorous third-party auditing to ensure NO monkey labor is used.*

The Bottom Line

1. Buy Native Forest "Simple". Make sure it says Simple. The "Classic" version has guar gum.

2. Shake clean cans vigorously. Since they lack emulsifiers, the cream will separate. This is natural. Run the can under hot water for 30 seconds if it's too solid.

3. Skip the "Lite" aisle. Buy full-fat and dilute it yourself. You'll get two cans for the price of one.

FAQ

Why is my coconut milk solid/chunky?

This is a good sign. It means there are no emulsifiers (gums) keeping it artificially smooth. The fat (coconut cream) separates from the water at room temperature. Scoop the cream for desserts, or melt it back in for curries.

Is Aroy-D coconut milk safe?

Ingredient-wise, the carton version is excellent (100% coconut milk). However, the canned version often contains Polysorbate 60. Ethically, the brand is flagged by PETA for monkey labor, so we recommend avoiding it if animal welfare is a priority.

Can I freeze leftover coconut milk?

Yes. Pour leftovers into an ice cube tray. Once frozen, pop them into a bag. They are perfect for throwing directly into smoothies or curries later.

What is BPA-NI?

BPA-Non-Intent. It means BPA was not intentionally added to the can lining. It is currently the safest standard for canned goods, though it doesn't guarantee zero migration from manufacturing equipment. For 100% safety, choose glass jars or aseptic cartons.

---

References (14)

1. 1. alibaba.com
2. 2. sentientmedia.org
3. 3. thekitchn.com
4. 4. peta.org.au
5. 5. theguardian.com
6. 6. theguardian.com
7. 7. peta.org
8. 8. peta.org.uk
9. 9. petaasia.com
10. 10. supplychaindigital.com
11. 11. alibaba.com
12. 12. edwardandsons.com
13. 13. importfood.com
14. 14. millerco.com