The Short Answer
Yes, but it's rare now. About 95% of canned foods produced today are BPA-free. Public outcry and voluntary industry shifts have largely eliminated Bisphenol A (BPA) from the can linings of major brands like Campbellās, General Mills, and Trader Joeās.
However, the verdict is Caution because of what replaced it. Manufacturers swapped BPA for other synthetic materialsātypically polyester, acrylic, or polyvinyl chloride (PVC). While polyester and acrylic are generally considered safer, PVC is a known toxicant. A "BPA-Free" label does not guarantee a safe can; it just means they used a different chemical to line it.
Why This Matters
BPA (Bisphenol A) is a potent endocrine disruptor. It mimics estrogen in the body, linked to reproductive issues, developmental problems in children, and increased cancer risk. It leaches from the epoxy lining of cans into the foodāespecially in acidic foods like tomatoes.
The industry solved the PR problem by removing BPA, but they didn't necessarily solve the toxicity problem. This is known as "regrettable substitution."
* BPS (Bisphenol S) is often used to replace BPA in thermal paper and plastics, and itās just as toxic.
* PVC (Vinyl) is used in some can linings but is made from vinyl chloride, a known carcinogen.
You aren't just trying to avoid BPA; you are trying to avoid leaching plastics entirely.
What's Actually In Your Can
Cans are not just metal; they are lined with a thin plastic coating to prevent the metal from reacting with the food. Here are the three main types of linings used today:
- Oleoresin ā The Gold Standard. A mixture of oil and plant resin (usually pine or balsam fir). It is natural and safe. Eden Foods Beans Review
- Polyester & Acrylic ā The Industry Standard. Most "BPA-Free" cans use these plastics. They are synthetic but currently considered safer than BPA or PVC.
- Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC/Vinyl) ā The Red Flag. Often listed as "vinyl" or "vinyl organosol." PVC contains phthalates and is created using vinyl chloride, a carcinogen.
What to Look For
Green Flags:
- "Oleoresin Lining" ā Explicitly stated by brands like Eden Foods.
- Glass Jars ā The only way to be 100% sure no lining is leaching.
- "BPA-NI" ā Stands for "BPA Non-Intent." Means BPA wasn't added. Usually implies polyester/acrylic lining.
Red Flags:
- "Vinyl" or "PVC" ā If a brand mentions "food-grade vinyl," put it back.
- Acidic Foods in Cans ā Tomatoes, pineapples, and citrus degrade linings faster, increasing leaching of whatever chemical is there.
- Dented Cans ā Dents crack the internal lining, allowing metal and plastic chemicals to migrate directly into the food.
The Best Options
Not all "BPA-Free" cans are created equal. Here is how the top brands stack up based on their lining materials.
| Brand | Product | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eden Foods | Beans | ā | Oleoresin lining. The safest can on the market. |
| Jovial | Tomatoes | ā | Glass jars. No plastic lining to worry about. |
| Native Forest | Coconut Milk | ā ļø | BPA-NI. Uses polyester/acrylic. Acceptable, but still plastic. Native Forest Coconut Milk Review |
| Trader Joe's | All Cans | ā ļø | BPA-Free. Uses polyester/acrylic. Good, but lacks transparency. |
| Muir Glen | Tomatoes | š« | Vinyl. Historically uses vinyl-based liners. Avoid. |
| Crown Prince | Seafood | š« | Vinyl. Uses "vinyl organosol" lacquer. |
The Bottom Line
1. Buy Beans from Eden Foods. They are the only major brand using plant-based oleoresin liners. It's worth the extra dollar.
2. Buy Tomatoes in Glass. Acidic tomatoes destroy can linings. Brands like Jovial and Bionaturae sell in glass.
3. Rinse Your Canned Food. Rinsing beans and vegetables can reduce residual BPA or other lining chemicals by up to 40%.
FAQ
Does "BPA-Free" mean safe?
Not always. It often means the BPA was replaced with PVC (vinyl) or acrylic. While acrylic is better, PVC is a toxic "regrettable substitution" linked to carcinogens.
Which canned foods are the most dangerous?
Canned tomatoes. Their high acidity breaks down the plastic lining, causing more chemicals (BPA or its replacements) to leach into the sauce. Always buy tomatoes in glass jars. Best Canned Tomatoes
Do Trader Joeās cans have BPA?
No. Trader Joeās states their cans are BPA-free (excluding some lids). They use a polyester/acrylic lining, which is acceptable but not as clean as oleoresin.
References (16)
- 1. lifewithoutplasticblog.com
- 2. oregonstate.edu
- 3. greenscreenchemicals.org
- 4. ireadlabelsforyou.com
- 5. newfoodmagazine.com
- 6. gimmethegoodstuff.org
- 7. leafscore.com
- 8. leafscore.com
- 9. wordpress.com
- 10. trellis.net
- 11. ewg.org
- 12. cornucopia.org
- 13. reddit.com
- 14. safefood.net
- 15. safemama.com
- 16. naturalvalue.com