The Short Answer
Native Shampoo is better than Pantene, but it isn't truly clean.
It scores a "Caution" verdict because of one major red flag: Fragrance. Native uses a proprietary blend of "safe synthetic oils" and essential oils but refuses to disclose the full ingredient list. In the world of non-toxic living, lack of transparency is an automatic fail.
Additionally, since 2024, the brand has faced consumer backlash and potential lawsuits regarding hair loss and scalp irritation. If you must use Native, stick to the Unscented version, which avoids the most problematic ingredients.
Why This Matters
Native is often the first stop for people switching to natural products. It's accessible, affordable, and owned by Procter & Gambleāthe same giant behind Herbal Essences and Head & Shoulders. This ownership matters because it signals a shift from "craft" formulations to mass-market industrial chemistry.
The "Fragrance" Loophole:
Federal law allows companies to list "Fragrance" as a single ingredient to protect trade secrets. This one word can hide over 3,000 different chemicals, including endocrine disruptors and allergens. Native claims their fragrance is phthalate-free, but without a full list, you are trusting a corporation, not verifying facts. Is Fragrance In Body Wash Bad
The Hair Loss Connection:
"Clean" doesn't always mean gentle. The use of Cocamidopropyl Betaine (a coconut-derived cleanser) is standard in sulfate-free shampoos, but it is a known contact allergen. High concentrations combined with synthetic fragrance can trigger scalp inflammation, leading to the shedding many users are reporting.
What's Actually In Native Shampoo
Native prides itself on a simple ingredient list (usually around 10 items). Here is the breakdown of their popular Coconut & Vanilla formula:
- Water ā The base solvent.
- Sodium Cocoyl Isethionate ā A gentle surfactant derived from coconut oil. Generally safe.
- Lauramidopropyl Betaine ā A cleansing agent and foam booster. Can cause irritation in sensitive skin.
- Cocamidopropyl Betaine ā A surfactant that replaces sulfates. It was named the "Allergen of the Year" in 2004 by the American Contact Dermatitis Society. Safest Shampoo
- Sodium Lauroyl Sarcosinate ā A foaming agent. Safe, but often confused with sulfates (it's not one).
- Fragrance (Parfum) ā The Red Flag. An undisclosed mixture of natural and synthetic scents.
- Sodium Benzoate ā A preservative. Safer than parabens, but can react with Vitamin C to form benzene (rare in shampoo, but worth noting). Is There Benzene In Dry Shampoo
- Sodium Salicylate ā A salt of salicylic acid, used as a preservative.
- Polyquaternium-10 ā A synthetic polymer that coats hair to reduce static. It can cause buildup if you don't wash thoroughly. Is Silicone In Shampoo Bad
- Citric Acid ā Adjusts pH levels. Safe.
What to Look For
Green Flags:
- Sulfate-Free: No SLS or SLES, meaning it won't strip hair as aggressively as traditional shampoos. Is Sulfate In Shampoo Bad
- Paraben-Free: Uses safer food-grade preservatives.
- Accessible: Available at almost every grocery store, making "better" choices easier for the masses.
Red Flags:
- "Fragrance" Listed: The vague term that hides synthetic chemicals.
- Cocamidopropyl Betaine: A common trigger for those with eczema or sensitive scalps.
- Lack of Organic Ingredients: "Derived from" coconut does not mean organic or pesticide-free.
The Best Options
If you love the brand but hate the risk, the choice is simple.
| Brand | Product | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Native | Unscented Shampoo | ā | Removes the #1 toxin (Fragrance). |
| Native | Cucumber & Mint | ā ļø | Contains "Fragrance" and potential allergens. |
| Native | Coconut & Vanilla | ā ļø | The most complaints regarding hair loss often stem from this bestseller. |
The Bottom Line
1. Skip the Scent: If you buy Native, buy Unscented. It is the only way to ensure you aren't applying hidden synthetics.
2. Monitor Your Scalp: If you experience itching or increased shedding within the first 3 washes, stop immediately. This is a common reaction to their surfactant blend.
3. Don't Trust the "Clean" Label: Native is "Clean-Washing"āusing minimalist marketing to sell a standard chemical formula. For truly non-toxic hair care, look for brands like Innersense or Under Luna. Is Innersense Shampoo Clean
FAQ
Does Native shampoo cause hair loss?
Yes, for some users. Thousands of complaints and class-action investigations allege that Native shampoo causes hair thinning and shedding. This is likely due to a reaction to the preservatives or the surfactant Cocamidopropyl Betaine, which can cause scalp inflammation that triggers hair fall.
Is Native shampoo sulfate-free?
Yes. Native uses alternative surfactants like Sodium Cocoyl Isethionate. While these are gentler than sulfates, they are still highly processed detergents that can be stripping for some hair types. Should You Use Sulfate Free Shampoo
Is Native owned by a big corporation?
Yes. Native was acquired by Procter & Gamble (P&G) in 2017 for $100 million. Since the acquisition, production has scaled up, and many purists argue the formulation quality has shifted to maximize profit over purity.
References (14)
- 1. ians.in
- 2. incidecoder.com
- 3. lemon8-app.com
- 4. hims.com
- 5. organicallybecca.com
- 6. ewg.org
- 7. ewg.org
- 8. nuniq.io
- 9. sustaimarket.com
- 10. ewg.org
- 11. skinsort.com
- 12. lawbhoomi.com
- 13. theminihints.com
- 14. ubuy.com.pr