The Short Answer
Is Purell safe? Yes, mostly. Unlike dozens of pop-up brands that were recalled for containing toxic methanol or cancer-causing benzene during the pandemic, Purell has maintained a clean safety record.
However, "safe" doesn't always mean "clean." The classic Purell bottle you see everywhere contains synthetic fragrance and dyes (in some versions) that can trigger allergies or skin irritation. While it won't poison you, it's not the cleanest option on the shelf.
The Verdict: If you use Purell, swap the classic green bottle for Purell Naturals or Purell Fragrance Free. They offer the same hospital-grade germ-killing power without the unnecessary chemical additives.
Why This Matters
Hand sanitizer became a survival tool in 2020, but it also became a chemical minefield. Independent testing by Valisure found that 17% of hand sanitizer samples contained benzene, a known carcinogen linked to leukemia.
While Purell passed these tests with flying colors (no benzene detected), the brand still relies on 70% Ethyl Alcohol. While effective, alcohol is a solvent that strips your skin's natural oils. Combine that with synthetic fragrancesāwhich are legally allowed to hide hundreds of chemicals under one labelāand you have a recipe for chronic dermatitis and compromised skin barriers.
Using a safe sanitizer matters because you likely use it multiple times a day. You shouldn't have to trade your long-term health to kill a few germs. Is Hand Sanitizer Safe
What's Actually In Purell
Purell's ingredient list is relatively short, but there are important distinctions between their product lines. Here is what is in the standard "Advanced" gel:
- Ethyl Alcohol (70%) ā The active ingredient. It kills 99.99% of germs by breaking down their cell walls. Purell uses high-purity ethanol, avoiding the methanol contamination risks seen in cheaper brands.
- Water ā The solvent that helps the alcohol work (alcohol needs water to penetrate bacterial membranes).
- Isopropyl Alcohol ā A secondary alcohol often used as a denaturant (makes the mixture undrinkable).
- Fragrance (Parfum) ā The biggest red flag. In the standard version, this undisclosed mixture can contain phthalates and allergens. Is Fragrance In Hand Soap Bad
- Tocopheryl Acetate (Vitamin E) ā An antioxidant added to moisturize skin and offset the drying effects of alcohol.
- Carbomer / Acrylates ā Thickeners that give Purell its signature gel texture so it doesn't run off your hands like water.
- Aminomethyl Propanol ā A pH adjuster to ensure the gel remains stable.
What to Look For
When buying Purell (or any sanitizer), check the label for these specifics:
Green Flags:
- "Denatured with essential oils" ā Found in the Naturals line; indicates no synthetic scent.
- "Fragrance-Free" ā The gold standard for sensitive skin.
- "USP Grade Alcohol" ā Indicates pharmaceutical-grade purity, reducing the risk of benzene.
Red Flags:
- "Parfum" or "Fragrance" ā Unless followed by specific essential oil names (e.g., Citrus aurantium), assume it's synthetic.
- "Methanol" or "1-Propanol" ā Toxic forms of alcohol that should never be in your sanitizer (Purell does not use these).
- Benzalkonium Chloride ā An alcohol-free alternative often found in "gentle" sanitizers. It's less effective against viruses and is a known skin irritant. Safest Hand Sanitizer
The Best Options
Purell makes several versions. Here is how they stack up:
| Product | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Purell Naturals | ā Recommended | Uses plant-based ethanol and essential oils (Orange/Lavender). No synthetic fragrance. |
| Purell Fragrance Free | ā Recommended | The cleanest option. Zero scent, low irritation risk. Harder to find in stores. |
| Purell Advanced (Original) | ā ļø Acceptable | Safe from toxins, but contains synthetic fragrance. Good in a pinch. |
| Purell Surface Spray | ā ļø Caution | Often rated lower by EWG due to respiratory concerns from inhaling the spray. |
The Bottom Line
1. Trust the brand, not the scent. Purell is a reliable manufacturer that avoided the massive safety recalls of recent years. You can trust the alcohol inside is safe.
2. Go Natural. Switch to Purell Naturals or Purell Fragrance Free to avoid unnecessary synthetic chemicals.
3. Don't overdo it. Sanitizer is for when soap and water aren't available. Overusing it strips your skin microbiome and can lead to cracking, which actually invites more infection. Is Hand Soap Safe
FAQ
Does Purell contain benzene?
No. Independent testing by Valisure and internal quality controls have consistently shown Purell products to be free of benzene, a carcinogen found in many other sanitizer brands during the COVID-19 pandemic. Is Dry Shampoo Carcinogenic
Is Purell Naturals actually better?
Yes. While the germ-killing power (70% alcohol) is identical to the original, the Naturals line replaces synthetic "Fragrance" with essential oils and uses plant-based ethanol. It avoids the "black box" of fragrance chemicals.
Can Purell expire?
Yes. The FDA requires an expiration date because the alcohol can evaporate over time, dropping below the 60% threshold required to effectively kill germs. If your bottle is older than 3 years, toss it.
References (18)
- 1. incidecoder.com
- 2. staples.com
- 3. oppictures.com
- 4. csu.edu.au
- 5. martinsfoods.com
- 6. ewg.org
- 7. gojo.com
- 8. gojo.com
- 9. lowesfoods.com
- 10. ewg.org
- 11. ewg.org
- 12. forbes.com
- 13. foxbusiness.com
- 14. ottertail.mn.us
- 15. gojo.com
- 16. utah.edu
- 17. fairwaymarket.com
- 18. skinsafeproducts.com