What's the Healthiest Dog Treat? (Top Ranked Options)

The Short Answer

The healthiest dog treat is one ingredient.

Freeze-dried meats (like beef liver, chicken breast, or salmon) are the gold standard. They provide high-value protein without the fillers, sugars, and artificial preservatives found in most commercial biscuits. Brands like PureBites, Stella & Chewy's, and Open Farm lead the pack here.

If you want a chew, bully sticks or dehydrated sweet potatoes are superior to rawhide. If you are buying grocery store brands like Milk-Bone or Beggin' Strips, you are likely feeding your dog the canine equivalent of fast food—loaded with BHA/BHT preservatives and artificial dyes.

Why This Matters

Obesity is the #1 health threat to dogs in the US. Over 50% of American dogs are overweight, and high-calorie, processed treats are a primary culprit. Feeding "junk food" treats contributes to inflammation, poor gut health, and shorter lifespans.

Most owners violate the 10% Rule. Veterinarians agree that treats should make up no more than 10% of your dog's daily calories. For a 20-pound dog, that's only about 40 calories—roughly one large biscuit or a small handful of freeze-dried liver.

Ingredients matter more than marketing. Packages that say "Made with Real Beef" often contain more wheat flour and sugar than actual meat. Worse, preservatives like BHA and BHT are known carcinogens still legally allowed in pet food. Dog Treat Ingredients To Avoid

What's Actually In Popular Treats

Commercial treats are often a chemistry experiment. Here is what you are typically buying in a box of "bacon-flavored" strips:

• Wheat & Corn — Cheap fillers that spike blood sugar and offer little nutrition.
• Sugar & Corn Syrup — Added solely to addict your dog to the product. Dogs do not need added sugar.
• BHA/BHT — Synthetic preservatives linked to cancer in lab animals. Is Bha Bht In Dog Food Safe
• Red 40 / Yellow 5 — Artificial dyes used to make the treat look like "meat" to you. Your dog is colorblind to red; they don't care.

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• Single Ingredient — "100% Beef Liver" or "Dehydrated Sweet Potato."
• Freeze-Dried or Air-Dried — Processing methods that preserve nutrients without chemicals.
• Sourced in USA/NZ/Canada — Stricter safety standards than treats sourced from China. Are Dog Treats From China Safe

Red Flags:

• "Meat By-Product" — Vague meat sources that can include diseased tissues.
• Propylene Glycol — A moisture-retainer closely related to antifreeze (safe in small doses, but unnecessary).
• Rawhide — A leather industry by-product often treated with bleach and glue. Is Rawhide Safe For Dogs

The Best Options

We prioritized single-ingredient purity and sourcing safety.

The Bottom Line

1. Switch to freeze-dried. It’s the easiest upgrade. One bag of liver treats lasts weeks and costs nearly the same per serving as junk biscuits.

2. Read the label. If you see BHA, BHT, or Red 40, put it back.

3. Count the calories. Treat calories count. Reduce their dinner kibble slightly if you've had a heavy training day.

FAQ

Are Greenies healthy?

It depends. They are highly effective for dental hygiene and are VOHC-accepted. However, they are nutritionally poor, containing wheat gluten and glycerin. Use them for teeth cleaning, not as a nutritional reward. Is Greenies Safe

Can I just give my dog human food?

Yes, if chosen correctly. Blueberries, apple slices (no seeds), and baby carrots are fantastic, low-calorie treats. Avoid grapes, raisins, onions, and chocolate, which are toxic. Best Single Ingredient Dog Treats

Is rawhide really that bad?

Yes. It is a choking hazard and a digestive blockage risk. Most rawhide is also processed with harsh chemicals (like bleach) to make it white. Bully sticks or yak cheese are much safer alternatives. Is Rawhide Dangerous

---

References (21)

1. 1. chewy.com
2. 2. youtube.com
3. 3. kohapet.com
4. 4. devildogpetco.com
5. 5. zachspetshop.com.au
6. 6. kohapet.com
7. 7. boneandbiscuit.ca
8. 8. joyfullpet.com
9. 9. petzyo.com.au
10. 10. tartarshield.com
11. 11. getwag.com.au
12. 12. a-z-animals.com
13. 13. moundspet.com
14. 14. prouddogmom.com
15. 15. reddit.com
16. 16. pumpkin.care
17. 17. skipperspetproducts.com
18. 18. youtube.com
19. 19. dogster.com
20. 20. kwikpets.com
21. 21. pawsomeorganics.com