Is Open Farm Dog Food Good?

The Short Answer

Yes, Open Farm is excellent. It sets the gold standard for transparency in the pet food industry.

Most dog food brands are a "black box"—you have no idea where the meat comes from. Open Farm is different. You can scan the QR code on every bag to see the exact farm where the beef was raised and the lab test results for that batch.

If you are worried about the link between grain-free food and heart disease (DCM), Open Farm offers a perfect solution: their Ancient Grains line. Unlike many competitors, this specific line is completely free of peas, lentils, and legumes, making it one of the safest dry foods you can buy today.

Why This Matters

Mystery meat is the industry standard.

Most brands buy "meat meal" from giant aggregators. That "beef" could be old dairy cows, feedlot cattle, or worse. Open Farm uses GAP Step 4 Certified meat, meaning the animals were pasture-raised and treated humanely.

Transparency is safety.

In an industry plagued by recalls, knowing exactly where your ingredients come from is power. Open Farm tests every batch for pathogens and heavy metals, and unlike other brands, they publish the results for you to see.

The "Grain-Free" trap.

Many premium brands only offer grain-free food, which often relies on heavy amounts of peas and lentils. These ingredients are currently under FDA investigation for causing heart issues. Open Farm gives you a choice: legume-free Ancient Grains or traditional Grain-Free.

What's Actually In Open Farm (Ancient Grains Beef)

Here is the breakdown of their most popular "Ancient Grains" recipe. Notice what is missing: no peas, no potatoes.

• Humanely Raised Beef — The first ingredient. Sourced from certified high-welfare farms. No antibiotics or growth hormones.
• Oats & Millet — Ancient grains that provide fiber and energy without the cardiac risks associated with legumes. Is Grain Free Dog Food Safe
• Ocean Whitefish Meal — A concentrated protein source. "Meal" is good here because it's named (Whitefish, not "Fish Meal") and Ocean Wise certified sustainable.
• Coconut Oil — A source of medium-chain triglycerides (MCTs) for brain health and coat shine. Is Dog Shampoo Safe
• Pumpkin — Excellent for digestion and stool quality.

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• Traceability Code: Every bag has a lot code you can type into their website.
• Ethical Certifications: Look for the Global Animal Partnership (GAP) and Ocean Wise logos. These are third-party audits, not just marketing claims.
• "Legume-Free": specifically on the Ancient Grains bags. This is rare in the premium kibble market.

Red Flags:

• Grain-Free Recipes: Their grain-free line does use peas and lentils. Unless your dog has a diagnosed allergy to grains (which is rare), stick to the Ancient Grains line to minimize DCM risk. Does Grain Free Cause Heart Disease
• Recent Withdrawal: In December 2024, they voluntarily withdrew specific lots of freeze-dried food due to potential plastic film contamination. It wasn't a mandated recall, but it's a reminder to always check your lot codes.

The Best Options

Open Farm has a huge catalog. Here is how to navigate it.

The Bottom Line

1. Buy the "Ancient Grains" line. It offers all the benefits of premium meat without the potential heart risks of a grain-free diet.

2. Scan your bag. Use their transparency tool. It’s not just a gimmick; it confirms your batch passed safety tests.

3. Skip the Grain-Free. Unless your vet specifically prescribed a grain-free diet, there is no nutritional reason to choose it over the Ancient Grains option.

FAQ

Is Open Farm worth the high price?

Yes. You are paying for ethical sourcing and safety testing. While it costs more than Purina Is Purina Safe, it is significantly cheaper than fresh food subscriptions like The Farmer's Dog Is Farmers Dog Good while offering similar ingredient quality.

Has Open Farm ever had a recall?

Technically, no. They have never had a mandated FDA recall. However, they issued a voluntary withdrawal in Dec 2024 for select freeze-dried products due to potential plastic film contamination.

Is Open Farm good for puppies?

Yes. Their "Puppy" recipes are excellent. Again, we recommend the Ancient Grains Puppy formula over the grain-free one to ensure safe development without heavy legume exposure.

---

References (14)

1. 1. truthaboutpetfood.com
2. 2. dogbonemarket.com
3. 3. treatsonaleash.com
4. 4. krisers.com
5. 5. ketonaturalpetfoods.com
6. 6. caninejournal.com
7. 7. openfarmpet.com
8. 8. openfarmpet.com
9. 9. petful.com
10. 10. pawdiet.com
11. 11. powderbulksolids.com
12. 12. reddit.com
13. 13. thefishandbone.com
14. 14. reddit.com