⚠️
What Protein Powder Brands Have Been Recalled?
Even the biggest brands aren't immune to Class I recalls and undeclared allergens.
Search for categories and articles
Whey, plant-based, collagen, and everything in between — protein supplements are notorious for heavy metal contamination and misleading labels. We find the cleanest options that actually work.
44 topics
Even the biggest brands aren't immune to Class I recalls and undeclared allergens.
Because the FDA doesn't test supplements before they hit shelves, looking for third-party certifications is the only way to guarantee your protein powder isn't spiked with heavy metals or banned substances.
The FDA treats protein powder like a dietary supplement, meaning it hits the shelves before anyone actually verifies what's inside the tub.
A shocking 47% of top-selling protein powders fail heavy metal safety thresholds—here are the few brands that actually pass.
A shocking 47% of protein powders exceed safe limits for heavy metals, with plant-based options posing the highest risk for arsenic contamination.
Consumer Reports and the Clean Label Project found that 70% of plant-based protein powders fail heavy metal safety tests.
47% of protein powders exceed safety limits for heavy metals—and organic, plant-based options are actually the worst offenders.
Mainstream protein powders almost always use sucralose and Ace-K, but a new wave of clean brands are using monk fruit, stevia, or literally nothing at all.
That 25g of protein on your supplement label might actually be 15g of complete protein and 10g of cheap filler.
That 30g of protein on the label might actually be 18g of protein and 12g of cheap filler.
That 20-item ingredient list isn’t there for your health—it’s there to make a cheap, chalky powder mix like a milkshake.
That thick, creamy milkshake texture in your protein powder? It's likely caused by industrial gums that are wreaking havoc on your gut.
This seaweed-derived thickener was voted off the organic safe list for causing gut inflammation—but the USDA kept it anyway.
A single "natural flavor" can contain over 100 hidden chemicals, including synthetic solvents and preservatives.
It makes your shake smooth and clump-free, but this cheap emulsifier is usually extracted with neurotoxic hexane.
Stevia is a massive upgrade from artificial sweeteners, but the cheap bulk fillers it’s often blended with carry alarming cardiovascular risks.
A 2023 study found that a chemical inside sucralose effectively breaks up human DNA.
That 'sugar-free' protein shake might be doing more damage to your gut and heart than actual sugar.
If your protein shake leaves you bloated, the protein probably isn't the problem—the hidden sweeteners and gums are.
Casein isn't better than whey—it's just slower, taking up to 7 hours to digest compared to whey's rapid 90-minute absorption.
You're paying a premium for omega-3s and CLA that are almost entirely removed during the manufacturing process.
Whey isolate removes 99% of the lactose found in concentrate, making it the clear winner for sensitive stomachs.
Collagen has a protein quality score of exactly zero—but that doesn't mean you should throw it away.
Almost 47% of plant-based protein powders exceed safe limits for heavy metals—here are the ones that actually pass the test.
A 12-week clinical trial found zero statistical difference in muscle gains between pea and whey protein.
Clinical data shows whey protein doesn't cause systemic inflammation—in fact, it might actually reduce it.
Recent 2024 studies prove plant protein builds muscle just as well as whey—but 77% of plant powders fail heavy metal tests.
A massive 2025 consumer investigation found that plant-based protein powders contain up to 9 times more lead than dairy alternatives.
Some protein powders pack more sugar than a glazed donut, while popular 'zero sugar' options secretly rely on gut-wrecking artificial sweeteners.
Dietitians skip the flashy marketing and look for one non-negotiable feature: rigorous third-party testing.
The world's most popular protein powder aces heavy metal tests, but its ingredient list is packed with artificial additives.
Vega is a giant in plant-based protein, but multiple independent tests have caught their powders hiding alarming levels of heavy metals.
Garden of Life boasts flawless organic ingredients, but their plant-based formulas just failed major heavy metal tests for lead.
It's the #1 plant protein brand in America, but a recent Consumer Reports test found it contains 143% of the daily limit for lead.
47% of top-selling protein powders fail heavy metal safety tests—here are the brands that actually prove they're clean.
You only need one ingredient to build muscle, but most brands give you twenty.
Nearly half of all protein powders fail heavy metal safety tests—here are the minimal-ingredient brands that actually pass.
Yes, you can cook with protein powder—but using the wrong type will turn your muffins into rubbery hockey pucks.
The 30-minute 'anabolic window' is a myth—your muscles are actually primed for growth for up to 24 hours after a workout.
You don't need supplements to build muscle—in fact, whole foods absorb better and keep you fuller.
You don't need a shake to build muscle, and most Americans already eat 88 grams of protein a day.
High protein intake won't destroy healthy kidneys, but the heavy metals hiding in popular powders absolutely can.
Drinking more than two scoops a day won't build extra muscle—but it will drastically increase your heavy metal exposure.
Up to 70% of protein powder users experience bloating—usually thanks to hidden lactose, cheap gums, and artificial sweeteners.