The Short Answer
The short answer is no: vegan mayo is not automatically healthier than regular mayonnaise. Whether a mayo is plant-based or traditional, its health profile is entirely dictated by the type of oil used to make it.
Most mainstream vegan mayos use the exact same cheap seed oils as regular mayo. Swapping a traditional soybean oil mayo for a vegan canola oil mayo offers zero nutritional upgrade and leaves you consuming the same highly processed fats.
Why This Matters
Mayonnaise is essentially just an emulsion of oil and a binder. In regular mayo, egg yolks act as the glue that holds the oil and vinegar together, whereas vegan formulas rely on plant proteins. Is Mayo Bad For You
The eggs were never the real health problem. A single tablespoon of traditional mayo contains just a fraction of an egg yolk, contributing barely 5 to 10 milligrams of cholesterol. If you aren't strictly plant-based, there is no major health benefit to avoiding them.
The real health hazard in all condiments is the oil base. Cheap, highly refined oils like soybean and canola oil dominate grocery store shelves and drive up our intake of inflammatory omega-6 fatty acids. The only way to truly upgrade your health is to choose a better oil. Avocado Oil Mayo Healthier
What's Actually In Vegan Mayo
Vegan formulas replace eggs with plant-based alternatives, but the rest of the ingredient list often looks identical to traditional mayo. Oils In Mayonnaise
- Seed Oils — Most mainstream brands use canola or soybean oil as their primary ingredient, making them highly processed and inflammatory.
- Plant-Based Emulsifiers — Ingredients like aquafaba (chickpea broth), soy protein isolate, or potato protein replace the eggs to naturally bind the oil and water together.
- Thickeners and Gums — Vegan formulas often rely on modified food starch, xanthan gum, or guar gum to replicate a thick, spreadable texture. Is Hellmanns Mayo Clean
- Added Sugar — Some plant-based brands sneak in cane sugar or brown rice syrup to balance the flavor profile and hide the taste of the plant proteins.
What to Look For
Green Flags:
- 100% Avocado oil — This is the cleanest fat source for mayonnaise, providing heart-healthy monounsaturated fats. Cleanest Mayonnaise
- Simple plant proteins — Aquafaba or potato protein are clean, natural emulsifiers.
- Glass packaging — Prevents endocrine-disrupting chemicals from leaching into the high-fat condiment.
Red Flags:
- Soybean or canola oil — These highly processed oils are linked to inflammation and should be avoided entirely.
- Modified food starches — These are cheap, highly processed fillers used to mimic a creamy texture without using whole ingredients.
- Artificial preservatives — Ingredients like calcium disodium EDTA have no place in a clean condiment.
The Best Options
Finding a clean plant-based mayo means looking past the "vegan" label and focusing strictly on the oil quality.
| Brand | Product | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chosen Foods | Vegan Avocado Oil Mayo | ✅ | Uses 100% avocado oil and clean chickpea aquafaba. Chosen Foods Mayo Review |
| Primal Kitchen | Vegan Mayo | ✅ | Made with avocado oil and potato protein, and is completely sugar-free. Primal Kitchen Mayo Review |
| Hellmann's | Vegan Dressing and Spread | 🚫 | Relies entirely on inflammatory canola oil and modified food starch. |
The Bottom Line
1. Check the oil first. — Whether you buy vegan or regular mayo, avocado oil is always the superior choice over soybean or canola oil.
2. Watch for extra gums and starches. — Vegan products often require more artificial additives to mimic the properties of animal-based ingredients.
3. Don't fear the egg. — Unless you are strictly plant-based or have an allergy, high-quality organic eggs are a nutrient-dense whole food.
FAQ
Is vegan mayo lower in calories?
Vegan mayo has almost the exact same calorie count as regular mayo. Because both versions are primarily made of oil, they both clock in around 90 to 100 calories and 10 grams of fat per tablespoon. Is Mayo Bad For You
Does vegan mayo taste like regular mayo?
Most mainstream vegan mayos taste remarkably similar to the real thing. Brands have perfected the use of plant proteins and starches to seamlessly mimic the creamy, tangy profile of traditional mayonnaise.
Can I make my own vegan mayo?
Yes, you can easily blend avocado oil, aquafaba, and a splash of vinegar at home. Using an immersion blender creates a thick, creamy, and completely clean plant-based mayo in less than three minutes.
References (11)
- 1. bedda-world.nl
- 2. fairwaymarket.com
- 3. ochsner.org
- 4. strengthandsunshine.com
- 5. asparkleofgenius.com
- 6. socialnature.com
- 7. lovingitvegan.com
- 8. cspi.org
- 9. chosenfoods.com
- 10. cookunity.com
- 11. desireerd.com