The Short Answer
The ultimate verdict is that it depends entirely on the specific brand you buy. Conventional disposable pads are an environmental nightmare loaded with plastics and hormone disruptors, but many popular period underwear brands are contaminated with toxic "forever chemicals."
For the safest and most sustainable cycle, verified PFAS-free period underwear is the clear winner. If you prefer disposable options, you must stick to 100% organic, unbleached cotton pads to avoid the harsh volatile organic compounds (VOCs) found in drugstore brands. Period Underwear Vs Pads
Why This Matters
Comparing period underwear and pads isn't just a matter of comfortāit's a choice between two entirely different types of toxic exposure. Traditional disposable pads sit directly against highly permeable vaginal tissue, giving synthetic chemicals a fast track into your bloodstream. Are Pads Safe
The environmental toll of disposable pads is staggering. The average menstruating person uses up to 17,000 disposable products in their lifetime. Because standard pads are made of up to 90% plastic, each one takes roughly 500 to 800 years to break down in a landfill. Is Plastic In Pads Bad
Period underwear solves this massive plastic waste crisis, but it introduces a new chemical threat. Independent lab testing has found PFAS "forever chemicals" in 65% of period underwear brands. You have to know exactly what you are buying to avoid swapping plastic pollution for permanent chemical buildup in your body. Is There Pfas In Period Underwear
What's Actually In These Products
- Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) ā Found in many conventional scented pads. These industrial chemicals vaporize at room temperature and have been linked to reproductive harm. Are There Chemicals In Pads
- PFAS "Forever Chemicals" ā Used as waterproofing agents in many period underwear brands. PFAS are linked to hormonal disruptions, fertility issues, and immune system suppression. Which Period Underwear Has Pfas
- Superabsorbent Polymers (SAPs) ā The petroleum-derived gel inside most conventional pads. SAPs hold massive amounts of liquid but lock in moisture and heat, increasing the risk of bacterial infections. Are Scented Pads Bad
- Phthalates & Bisphenols ā Plasticizers often used in conventional pad backings and wrappers. A recent 2025 university study found these endocrine-disrupting chemicals in 100% of the conventional pads they tested.
What to Look For
Green Flags:
- Third-party PFAS testing ā Look for period underwear brands that actively test their final products and publish their non-detect results. Period Underwear No Pfas
- 100% certified organic cotton ā For pads, this ensures you aren't being exposed to pesticide residues like glyphosate. Are Organic Pads Worth It
Red Flags:
- "Stain-resistant" or "waterproof" claims ā In period underwear, these marketing buzzwords are often code for toxic PFAS chemical treatments. Is Period Underwear Safe
- Synthetic fragrances ā In pads, "odor control" usually means a cocktail of undisclosed synthetic chemicals that irritate sensitive tissue.
The Best Options
If you want the environmental benefits of reusable underwear without the chemical burden, you must choose verified clean brands. Check our full guides on the Safest Period Underwear and Safest Pad Brand for a deeper dive.
| Brand | Product | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Saalt | Period Underwear | ā | Scored non-detect for PFAS in recent Mamavation testing. Is Saalt Period Underwear Clean |
| Rael | Organic Cotton Pads | ā | Made with 100% organic cotton and zero synthetic fragrances. Is Rael Pads Clean |
| Thinx | Period Underwear | ā ļø | Settled a major lawsuit over PFAS contamination, though they claim to be clean now. Does Thinx Have Pfas |
| Always | Ultra Thin Pads | š« | Made with synthetic plastics, SAPs, and artificial fragrance cocktails. Is Always Pads Safe |
The Bottom Line
1. Invest in PFAS-free period underwear. It is the most sustainable option and eliminates monthly plastic waste, but you must verify the brand's testing data. Safest Period Underwear
2. Never buy scented conventional pads. If you use disposables, choose 100% organic cotton pads to avoid phthalates, VOCs, and synthetic plastics. Are Scented Pads Bad
3. Don't fall for "chemical-free" marketing. Recent studies show even some "natural" disposable pads contain hormone-disrupting chemicals due to manufacturing contamination.
FAQ
Is period underwear better for the environment than pads?
Yes, reusable underwear significantly reduces your lifetime carbon footprint. While manufacturing them requires more energy upfront, one pair can replace up to 200 disposable pads, keeping hundreds of years' worth of plastic out of landfills.
Does all period underwear have PFAS in it?
No, but you must be incredibly careful which brand you choose. While historical testing found PFAS in 65% of brands, companies like Saalt and Knix have reformulated and recently scored non-detect in independent lab testing. Thinx Vs Knix
Are organic pads actually safer?
Organic pads are safer than conventional, but they aren't perfect. They eliminate direct pesticide exposure and synthetic fragrances, but some independent testing has still found trace levels of phthalates migrating from the plastic backing. Are Organic Pads Worth It